Just use information from any old Web site? No way!Learning to evaluate Web sites is an incredibly important tool for both students and teachers to acquire. Although I have evaluated Web sites I planned to use for research on my own in the past, using Kathy Schrock's critical evaluation surveys gave me a better idea of what to look for on the sites I chose to evaluate.
Schrock's tools made it much easier to focus my observations on things that really mattered to my thoughts of the site's usefulness as well as the integrity of a site's author, the legitimacy of the information, and the attractiveness of the design. Overall, the evaluation surveys provided me with more tools I could use to determine whether or not a site was a good one.
For example, in the past I would probably only have considered the number of links that provided information on a site rather than thinking about the design of the site or the appeal of the links and whether or not they worked in a plain text format.
Students need to learn how to effectively evaluate Web sites because our world is so technologically-dependent now that they will continue to have to use the Web for research for their entire academic careers and beyond. If they use information from sites they have not evaluated, then they run the risk of using incorrect information in their school work or believing misinformation. In learning to recognize the legitimacy of a site like Albany University's Center on English Learning & Achievement (www.albany.edu/cela/), they learn to identify the things that are wrong with another site, such as the lack of well-developed lesson plans on Teachers.net. Additionally, students can learn that many sites are legitimate and useful even when not backed by a college, university, or other organization. For example, I found Vocabulary.com to be an incredibly useful site in spite of the fact that it was developed by a former teacher rather than a college or university.
Overall, I found the Web site evaluation exercise to be very useful. It gave me additional ideas for what to focus on when deciding whether or not a Web site will prove to be legitimate and practical. It also made me think about things I had not considered in the past, such as appeal.